Asacol (Mesalamine) vs Alternatives: Comprehensive Comparison

Asacol vs Alternatives: Treatment Selector

Recommended Treatment Plan

Key Takeaways

  • Asacol is a once‑daily mesalamine tablet; other mesalamine brands differ in release technology and dosing frequency.
  • Biologic and small‑molecule options (Remicade, Humira, Entyvio, Xeljanz) are reserved for moderate‑to‑severe disease or when mesalamine fails.
  • Cost varies widely: generic mesalamine is cheapest, while biologics can exceed $30,000 per year.
  • Side‑effect profiles range from mild GI upset with mesalamine to serious infection risk with biologics.
  • Choosing the right therapy hinges on disease severity, previous response, insurance coverage, and personal preferences.

When you search for Asacol vs alternatives, you want a clear side‑by‑side view of the options on the market. This guide breaks down the most common ulcerative colitis (UC) medicines, compares their key attributes, and helps you figure out which one fits your situation.

What Is Asacol?

Asacol is a mesalamine (5‑aminosalicylic acid) tablet designed for once‑daily dosing. It uses a pH‑dependent coating that releases the drug in the terminal ileum and colon, where inflammation usually occurs. Approved by the FDA in 1996, Asacol is indicated for mild to moderate UC and works by reducing local inflammation.

Typical dosing ranges from 2.4g to 4.8g per day, taken as a single tablet or split into two doses. Because it stays in the gut and is minimally absorbed, systemic side effects are rare, but some patients experience nausea, headache, or a mild rash.

Other Mesalamine Formulations

Pentasa is a mesalamine granule that can be swallowed or mixed with food, offering flexible dosing throughout the day. It’s often chosen for patients who have trouble swallowing tablets.

Lialda delivers mesalamine in a delayed‑release tablet taken once daily, similar to Asacol but with a different coating technology that targets the colon more uniformly.

Apriso provides a multimatrix system that releases mesalamine continuously over 24hours, allowing for a single daily dose without the need for a pH‑triggered coating.

Salofalk is the European brand name for mesalazine, available in tablets, granules, and rectal forms; it’s frequently prescribed outside the United States.

Watercolor shelf showing various mesalamine products beside a clinic scene with IV bag, syringe, and tablets.

When Mesalamine Isn’t Enough: Biologic and Small‑Molecule Options

If symptoms persist despite optimal mesalamine therapy, physicians may step up to biologics or oral small‑molecule agents.

Remicade (infliximab) is an intravenous anti‑TNF‑alpha antibody administered every 8weeks after induction. It’s effective for moderate‑to‑severe UC and for patients with fistulizing disease.

Humira (adalimumab) is a subcutaneous anti‑TNF agent given every 2 weeks, offering the convenience of home injection.

Entyvio (vedolizumab) is an integrin blocker given intravenously; it specifically targets gut‑homing lymphocytes, reducing systemic infection risk.

Xeljanz (tofacitinib) is an oral Janus kinase inhibitor taken twice daily, approved for UC patients who have failed conventional therapy.

Side‑Effect Snapshot

  • Mesalamine (Asacol, Pentasa, Lialda, Apriso, Salofalk): mild GI upset, headache, rarely nephrotoxicity.
  • Anti‑TNF agents (Remicade, Humira): increased infection risk, infusion reactions, possible lymphoma.
  • Vedolizumab (Entyvio): lower systemic infection rates but can cause liver enzyme elevations.
  • Tofacitinib (Xeljanz): risk of shingles, blood clots, and lipid elevation; requires regular labs.

Cost Considerations

Price is a major factor. Generic mesalamine (often sold as “mesalamine” without a brand name) can be as low as $0.10 per 500mg tablet when using discount programs. Branded Asacol typically costs $3‑$5 per 800mg tablet, translating to $1,200‑$2,400 per year.

Biologics are significantly more expensive: Remicade and Humira average $30,000‑$35,000 annually, while Entyvio sits around $28,000. Xeljanz, despite being oral, can still cost $20,000 per year.

Insurance formularies, patient assistance programs, and pharmacy savings cards can dramatically lower out‑of‑pocket expenses. It’s worth checking each manufacturer’s copay‑assist portal.

3D office scene with patient and doctor viewing a holographic treatment decision diagram.

Comparison Table

Key attributes of Asacol and major alternatives
Brand Formulation Typical Daily Dose FDA Approval Year Average Wholesale Price (USD) Primary Use Common Side Effects
Asacol pH‑dependent tablet 2.4‑4.8g 1996 $1,800‑$2,400/yr Mild‑moderate UC Headache, nausea
Pentasa Granules (oral/food) 2.0‑4.0g 1990 $1,500‑$2,200/yr Mild‑moderate UC Abdominal pain
Lialda Delayed‑release tablet 2.4‑4.8g 2004 $1,900‑$2,600/yr Mild‑moderate UC Headache, constipation
Apriso Multimatrix tablet 2.4‑4.8g 2003 $2,000‑$2,800/yr Mild‑moderate UC Nausea, flatulence
Salofalk Tablet / granule / enema 2.0‑4.0g 1995 (EU) $1,200‑$2,000/yr Mild‑moderate UC Diarrhea, headache
Remicade IV infusion 5mg/kg at weeks 0,2,6 then q8w 1998 $30,000‑$35,000/yr Moderate‑severe UC Infection, infusion reaction
Humira Subcutaneous injection 40mg q2w 2002 $32,000‑$36,000/yr Moderate‑severe UC Injection site pain, infection
Entyvio IV infusion 300mg q8w after induction 2014 $28,000/yr Moderate‑severe UC Liver enzymes, headache
Xeljanz Oral tablet 10mg bid 2018 $20,000/yr UC refractory to other therapy Shingles, clot risk

How to Choose the Right Therapy

Think of the decision as a flowchart:

  1. Assess disease severity: mild, moderate, or severe.
  2. Start with a mesalamine that matches your dosing preference (once‑daily tablet vs granules vs enema).
  3. If symptoms persist after 8‑12 weeks, verify adherence, then consider stepping up to a biologic or small‑molecule.
  4. Check insurance coverage and patient‑assistance eligibility before committing.
  5. Discuss potential side effects with your gastroenterologist; weigh infection risk versus convenience.

For example, a young professional who dislikes injections may stay on Asacol or Lialda as long as disease control is adequate. Conversely, a patient with frequent flares despite maximum mesalamine will likely need Remicade or Humira.

Practical Tips to Maximize Benefits

  • Take mesalamine with food to reduce nausea.
  • Never split a coated tablet (like Asacol) unless instructed-splitting destroys the pH‑release mechanism.
  • Set up automated pharmacy deliveries to avoid missed doses.
  • Schedule lab monitoring (creatinine for mesalamine; CBC, LFTs for biologics).
  • Enroll in manufacturer copay‑assist programs as soon as the prescription is written.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I switch between different mesalamine brands?

Yes, but you should do it under a doctor's supervision. Different brands have distinct release mechanisms, so the dose may need adjustment to maintain the same level of colon exposure.

What if I miss a dose of Asacol?

Take the missed tablet as soon as you remember, unless it’s almost time for the next dose. Then skip the missed one-don’t double up, because a higher local concentration can increase irritation.

Are biologics safe for patients with a history of infections?

Biologics, especially anti‑TNF agents, raise infection risk. Your doctor will screen for latent TB, hepatitis, and current infections before starting therapy and will monitor you regularly.

How do I know if my ulcerative colitis is severe enough for a biologic?

Indicators include frequent bloody stools (more than 4per day), anemia, weight loss, or steroid dependence. Endoscopic findings of extensive inflammation also push clinicians toward biologics.

Does insurance typically cover all these options?

Coverage varies. Generic mesalamine is usually covered with low copays. Branded mesalamine may be tier‑2 or tier‑3. Biologics often require prior authorization and may have higher out‑of‑pocket costs, but many manufacturers offer assistance.

Write a comment